Fans believe Taylor performed ‘Bigger Than The Whole Sky’ as an Eras Tour surprise song in tribute to three fans who sadly lost their lives this past week – Ana, Gabriel and Ally.
After a week that saw the tragic death of three Swifties, Taylor Swift took to the stage on her Eras Tour to perform her emotional ballad ‘Bigger Than the Whole Sky’. Fans believe she chose that specific song to pay tribute to the Swifties who sadly passed away.
Taylor is currently in Rio de Janeiro where she is performing the first of her two Eras Tour weekends in Brazil, heading to São Paulo later this week for the second. The country is currently experiencing a heatwave which has made conditions both outside and inside the stadium incredibly difficult for fans, as well as Taylor herself.
Other emotional verses included: ‘No words appear before me in the aftermath/ Salt streams out my eyes and into my ears/ Every single thing I touch becomes sick with sadness.’
‘Taylor Swift did a beautiful job honoring all the Swifties taken too soon,’ one fan tweeted, while another wrote that the performance was a ‘yet beautiful moment.’
‘I feel like we are all going to remember this one tonight. Whether it be live in Brazil or anywhere in the world,’ the second fan explained.
A third tweeted: ‘I already have immense respect for @taylorswift13 but after tonight’s surprise song, it has tripled. That must have been so hard for her to perform, for the original meaning and why she chose to play it tonight.’
In response to a TikTok video, uploaded by a fan under the username @tswift_22, Swifties applauded the performance that they perceived to be ‘for Ana.’
‘She played it for the girl who died, I’m gonna cry,’ one wrote.
Another speculated: ‘She played her heart out on that piano, you can tell she was doing it all for Ana.’
Others pointed out how Swift ‘was crying’ as she sang and you could ‘hear’ Swift’s raw emotion as she grieved for her fan.
Emotional: While seemingly paying her respects to her late fan, 23, the chart‑topping global superstar, 33, performed her gut-wrenching ballad, Bigger Than the Whole Sky, about grieving a premature loss, as the show’s second surprise song
Mourning: As she pushed through an emotional few days, which also included the fatal stabbing of a 25-year-old Swiftie, named Gabriel Milhomem Santos, and death of superfan Ally Anderson , following a five-year battle with cancer, the 12-time Grammy winner got visibly choked up while mourning the recent tragedies in her community
‘Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye / You were bigger than the whole sky / You were more than just a short time,’ Swift sang, prompting attendees to sob from their seats. ‘I’m never gonna meet / What could’ve been, would’ve been / What should’ve been you / What could’ve been, would’ve been you’
Not a dry eye in the house: The Amsterdam actress’ voice quivered as she attempted to get through singing the lyrics: ‘Did some force take you because I didn’t pray?’
On X (previously known as Twitter, one fan commented: ‘I can feel her hurt, the impact of what happened. Her voice… her emotion.’
On Friday, Benevides fainted in the front row and was given CPR by doctors at the scene but failed to revive her.
She was transported to a hospital, where she suffered a second cardiac arrest and died.
Earlier during the show, Swift, who had to postpone Saturday’s show due to sweltering temperatures, expressed gratitude to all her attendees for braving the record-breaking heat and rain to support her.
‘How lucky do you have to be to have 65,000 people dance in the pouring rain with you?’ she asked the crowd. ‘I’ve never gotten to bring a tour to Brazil before and you’ve been so supportive to me ever since the beginning of my career.’
Swift continued: ‘I love you so much and I’m so happy to see your faces tonight you have no idea.’
‘Taylor Swift did a beautiful job honoring all the Swifties taken too soon,’ one fan tweeted
Just before Taylor’s Friday (Nov 17) show began, Ana Clara Benevides Machado, who was standing at the barrier in the stadium waiting for the show to begin, sadly passed away after fainting and going into cardiac arrest.
Another two Swifties, Gabriel Mongenot Santana Milhomem Santos and Ally Garner Anderson, also sadly died last week.
Fans are now sharing their emotional footage of Taylor’s Surprise Song performance, and paying tribute to the Swifties who sadly lost their lives.
After postponing the second scheduled Eras Tour show in Rio, Taylor took to the stage on Sunday (Nov 19) to play for the huge crowds of fans inside the stadium. The show ended up being performed in the rain, which resulted in a slightly cooler temperature in the crowd and on stage.
When it came time for Taylor to perform her usual Surprise Songs, Swifties were hoping that she might perform the moving ‘Bigger Than the Whole Sky’ in honour of the Swifties who tragically passed away. And she did.
The Midnights track, in case you don’t know, is heartbreaking song about grief, and losing someone way too soon. In the chorus, Taylor sings: “Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye / You were bigger than the whole sky / You were more than just a short time.”
Fans around the stadium were moved to tears as she poured her heart and soul into performing the song on the piano. Replying to one comment, TikTok user and Swiftie @gustavo.gual said that “everyone was crying” as Taylor sang.
Sharing videos of Taylor’s performance, fans have been paying their respects to the fans who passed away.
On Friday (Nov 17), 23-year-old fan Ana Clara Benevides Machado tragically passed away after fainting and going into cardiac arrest before Taylor’s concert began. She had been queuing since 11am outside the stadium in the 35C heat, and had made it to the barrier inside the stadium before she collapsed.
Shortly after hearing about Ana’s death, Taylor released a statement on Instagram: “I can’t believe I’m writing these words but it is with a shattered heart that I say we lost a fan earlier tonight before my show. I can’t even tell you how devastated I am by this. There’s very little information I have other than the fact that she was so incredibly beautiful and far too young.”
“I’m not going to be able to speak about this from stage because I feel overwhelmed by grief when I even try to talk about it,” she continued. “I want to say now I feel this loss deeply and my broken heart goes out to her family and friends. This is the last thing I ever thought would happen when we decided to bring this tour to Brazil.”
In the early hours of Sunday morning (Nov 19), Gabriel Mongenot Santana Milhomem Santos, 25, also sadly died after he was reportedly killed in an attempted robbery before he even got to attend the show. Gabriel is said to have travelled to Rio for the concert.
On November 13th, Ally Garner Anderson, the Swiftie who received the ’22’ hat in Cincinnati, also sadly passed away. She had been living with cancer since 2018. She was 16 years old. Her mother Patty confirmed her passing to PEOPLE: “As you know Taylor Swift’s favorite number is 13. Ally passed away on 11/13/23 at 13:40. The 13th day during the 13th hour.”
Our thoughts are with the family and friends of Ana, Gabriel and Ally.